Tools: Cannibal tales

Cannibal tales: HCA 15/5 f.99

Editorial history

Created 18/05/13, by CSG

---

Purpose

This page is for the annotation of HCA 15/5 f.99.

Click on this link for HCA 15/5 f.99 to see a high definition image of the original manuscript image and the lastest edition of the transcription.

Annotations can be viewed by everyone on a read-only basis.

For more information on MarineLives and the MarineLives Annotation Project read our Shipping News blog entries:

Annotating Marine Lives, May 1st 2013
Adding value to primary documents, May 8th 2013
Witnesses in Court, 1657-1658 (May 9th, 2013)

---

Registration to annotate documents

Registration is required to contribute annotations to this page and to other pages in the wiki AnnotateHCA1372.

You can register using the following Register to Annotate HCA 13/72 contact form, and we will issue you with a UserName and Password for the wiki.

The same Username and Password will give you access to a companion MarineLives-Tools wiki. This companion wiki provides a range of tools to assist annotation.

---

Adding footnotes

• Go into edit mode

• Insert immediately after the sentence or phrase you wish to annotate the following macro:

<ref>This is the footnote text</ref>

• Replace 'This is the footnote text' with the footnote you wish to add, using the format: first name, surname, title, (place of publication, date of publication), page or folio number

• Save the page

---

Creating an electronic link within the footnote to a digital source

• Using the link icon in the top RH menu bar in your open window, highlight the footnote text which you wish to become the clickable link. This will place square brackets round the text, within the existing curved brackets

e.g. <ref>[Electronic link to a digital source]</ref>

• Insert the URL of the digital source IN FRONT of the existing text, but still within the square brackets, leaving one space between the end of the URL and the start of the footnote text

e.g. <ref>[http://XXXXX Electronic link to a digital source]</ref>

• Save the page, and the footnote text will now show 'Electronic link to a digital source' as a clickable link, which, when clicked, will go to 'http://XXXXX'

• FOOTNOTE TEMPLATE:

- HCA 13/72 f.XXXX Case: XXXX; Deposition: XXXX; Date: XXXX. Transcribed by XXXX

---

---

Suggested links

AnnotateHCA1372 Front_Page
MarineLives-Tools

---

HCA 15/5_f.99_Unfolded

INSERT IMAGE

---

Transcription

Current Transcription

<header>
<series>HCA 15/5</series>
<folio>f.99</folio>
<picture>P1150616</picture>
<summary></summary>
<document-date></document-date>
<status>First cut transcription started and completed on 18/05/13 by Colin Greenstreet</status>
<first-transcriber>Colin Greenstreet, 18/05/13</first-transcriber>
</header>

<document-start>
1. Petitio Prescilla Lockyer
2. presentat. 28th Septem
3. 1650./
4.
5. To the right worshipfull the Judges of the high Court of the Admiraltie:./
6. The humple petition of Priscilla Lockier and Sara Spurgeon wifes of Hugh Lockier and
7. George Spurgeon two of the Marriners of the Shipp the Virginia Merchant (whereof John
8. Lockier was Captaine or Comander./
9. Sheweth
10. That the petitioners husbands were hired by the said Captaine Lockier at severall monethly wages to serve in the said shipp for a voyage
11. to be made from this port of London to Virginia and from thense hither backe againe, which service they performed from
12. the 6th of September 1649 untill March last being 6 monethes lacking 4 dayes, but by reason the sayd Shipp was become
13. unserviceable at Virginia your petitioners husbands could not come home in her but are left behind to shift for themselves
14. the said Captaine Lockier and some others coming home as passengers in another Shippe And your petitioners seeing their husbands come
15. not home as they expected demanded their wages of the Captaine for the time they served him, but he denyed to pay the
16. same, for which your petitioners have sued the said Captaine Lockier in the Court And whereas all Masters of Shipps that goe to
17. Virginia use to carry 3 monethes ˹victualls˺ at the least out with them; The sayd Captaine Lockier had not layd in above 6 weekes
18. victualls in his said shipp when she sett saile from Gravesend outward bound; which Mr George Putt cheife Mate and pilot of
19. the said Shippe taking notice of, asked the said Captaine why he had soe slenderly victualled the shipp telling him, it would not
20. serve halfe way; he replyed that he would take in more victualls at the Downes which he did not at all performe
21. notwithstanding there were 35 seaman and above 130 passengers neere upon 200 persons in all in the said Shippe, whereof 62
22. passengers and 4 Seamen by reason of the want of provisions were starved to death before the shipp came to Virginia.
23.
24. That within a fortnight next after the said Ship set saile from Gravesend both Seamen and passingers were put to their allowance
25. videlicet the Seamen to two, and the passingers each man to one biskett a day, afterwards to halfe a biskett a day and at length to halfe a
26. pint of parched pease a day betweene 2 men, they having neither beere nor water in the shippe to drincke but what they were
27. Constrayned to drinkeof strongwaters of their owne which they Carried with them for adventures: and the famine came
28. soe violently upon them that divers in the said Shippe would willingly have given 10: s for one of the Shipps ratts (which some
29. of the Seamen catched) to have eaten, their being but one small fish of the value of 6: d allowed for a meale to 15 or 20 men:/
30. That the said Captaine Lockier sett 23 persons ashore upon an unknowne Island to gett freshwater promising to
31. fetch them on board againe: but after they were soe sett on shoare the sayd Captaine Lockier presently carried the Shippe
32. away to Virginia and most in humanely and barbarously left all the said 23 persons in that unknowne place to be starved there
33. noe manner of food to be found soe that they were forced to live a whole 3 weekes with water and the leaves of trees: And at the
34. length the rage and violence of their famine soe much increasing and being not able to eate those leaves and longer they cast
35. lotts which of them should be shott the next day to serve for food for the rest; which was miraculously prevented by the
36. suddaine and unexpected fall of a great tree that night which killed 2 men and a woman of their Company: which the rest of the Company
37. left alive were forced to eate and live upon untill such time as they were by Gods providence XXXXXXXX releived by the very
38. heathen and by them in Canoes transported over the river to the other side and soe travelled to Virginia by land where
39. divers of them dyed as soone as they came thense, and some dyed on that Island by famine./
40.
41. That the petitioners have spent all they have even their very {XXXX} from under them in prosecution of this suite to gett
42. their wages and are like to be utterly ruined and undone they having each of them a great Charge of Children to
43. bring up and maintaine all which premisses your petitioners are able to prove by the oathes of sufficient witnesses
44.
45. Your petitioners therefore most humbly pray that your worships would be pleased to take
46. their sad conditions into their your pious and serious Considerations, and to order
47. the sayd Captaine Lockier to pay your petitioners their whole wages due to their husbands
48. forthwith or els to give your petitioners leave to give in an allegation in Court to the effect
49. of the premisses above weitten: the same being altogether omitted in the allegation
50. given in on your petitioners behalfe; and to produce and examine witnesses thereupon, that
51. soe the iustice of your petitioners Cause and the great wrong they have received may appeare;
52.
53. And your petitioners as in humble duty
54. bound shall ever pray etcetera
55.
56. The marke of P L Prescillia Lockier
57. The marke of S Sara Sparges./
</document-end>

---

Comment

In their petition to the Right Worshipful Judges of the High Court of Admiralty, the wives of Hugh Lockier and George Spurgeon present a bleak view of the voyage of the Virginia Merchant and the behaviour of its master, Captain Lockier. They allege that he neglectfully set sail with inadequate victualls, and that as a consequence the crew and passengers were starved for much of the voyage, with a large number of deaths. Moreover, they assert that the captain deliberately and deceitfulyl left twenty three members of the crew and/or passengers on an island, on the pretext that they were to search for fresh water.

However, another account of the voyage exists, and was published under the title 'A Voyage to Virginia', authored by Colonel Norwood, one of the passengers.

Norwood's account notes at several points a paucity of victualls, but suggests that this was due to water damage, rather than inadequate initial provisioning.

In one passage he writes.

Before we attempted to bring the ship about, it was necessary to refresh the seamen, who were almost worn out with toil and want of rest, having had no leisure of eating set meals for many days. The passengers overcharged with excessive fears, had no appetite to eat; and (which was worst of all) both seamen and passengers were in a deplorable state as to the remaining victuals, all like to fall under extreme want; for the storm, by taking away the forecastle, having thrown much water into the hold, our stock of bread (the staff of life) was greatly damnified; and there remained no way to dress our meat, now that the cook-room was gone; the incessant tumbling of the ship (as has been observ'd) made all such cookery wholly impracticable. The only expedient to make fire betwixt decks, was, by sawing a cask in the middle, and filling it with ballast, which made a hearth to parch pease, and broil salt beef; nor could this be done but with great attendance, which was many times frustrated by being thrown topsy-turvy in spite of all circumspection, to the great defeat of empty stomachs.

Praising the skill and courage of Tom Reasin, one of the Virginia Merchant's, in scaling the surviving, but greasy and slippery, foremast to fasten a yard, Norwood confirms the HCA petition that biscuit rations went down to one per day per man:

We passed this night with greater alacrity than we had done any other since we had left Fyall; for mate Putts, our trusty pilot, did confidently affirm, that, if the gale stood, there would be no question of our dining the next day within the capes. This was seasonable news, our water being long since spent, our meat spoiled (or useless) no kind of victuals remaining to sustain life, but a bisket cake a day for a man; at which allowance there was not a quantity to hold out many days. In the dark time of the night, in tacking about, we lost our new comrade, and with much impatience we expected the approaching day

The badly damaged ship was frustratingly close to coast of Virginia, yet was unable to make land, and Norwood confirms that daily rations were further reduced to half a biscuit per man and woman per day, consistent with the High Court of Admiralty petitioners claim.

Defeated thus of lively hopes we had the night before entertain'd to sleep in warm beds with our friends in Virginia, it was a heavy spectacle to see our selves running at a round rate from it, notwithstanding all that could be done to the contrary. Nothing was now to be heard but sighs and groans thro' all that wretched family, which must be soon reduced to so short allowance, as would just keep life and soul together. Half a bisket cake a day to each (of which five whole ones made a pound) was all we had to trust to. Of liquors there remained none to quench thirst: Malaga sack was given plentifully to every one, which served rather to inflame and increase thirst, than to extinguish it.

The lack of food and drink is now described as an "intolerable want of all provisions, both of meat and drink" jostling all sense of happiness from the minds of the crew and passengers. "And to aggravate our misery yet the more, it was now our interest to pray, that the contrary gale might stand; for whilst the westerly wind held, we had rain water to drink, whereas at east the wind blew dry."

Driven increasingly far from the American shore, the crew and passengers debated whetehr it were best to make for the Bermudas or back to the Western Islands. Meanwhile:

The famine grew sharp upon us. Women and children made dismal cries and grievous complaints. The infinite number of rats that all the voyage had been our plague, we now were glad to make our prey to feed on; and as they were insnared and taken, a well grown rat was sold for sixteen shillings as a market rate. Nay, before the voyage did end (as I was credibly inform'd) a woman great with child offered twenty shillings for a rat, which the proprietor refusing, the woman died.

The passengers had embarked in mid-September, some in London and some at the Downes, and should long have been at Jamestown. Yet come Christmas day, they were still at sea.

Norwood again:

The blessed feast of Christmas came upon us, which we began with a very melancholy solemnity; and yet, to make some distinction of times, the scrapings of the meal-tubs were all amassed together to compose a pudding. Malaga sack, sea water, with fruit and spice, all well fryed in oyl, were the ingredients of this regale which raised some envy in the spectators; but allowing some privilege to the captain's mess, we met no obstruction, but did peaceably enjoy our Christmas pudding.

Norwood's greatest ompatience was of thirst:

My dreams were all of cellars, and taps running down my throat, which made my waking much the worse by that tantalizing fancy. Some relief I found very real by the captain's favour in allowing me a share of some butts of small claret he had concealed in a private cellar for a dead lift. It wanted a mixture of water for qualifying it to quench thirst; however, it was a present remedy, and a great refreshment to me.

Until this moment in Norwood's account there has been little mention of the ship's captain. Instead it is the chief mate, XXX Putt, who is singled out for comment, and broad praise. But after the Christmas feast, the captain extended Norwood the favour of going in search of water at the bottoms of the empty casks in the hold. Sitting astride on a butt of Malaga in the hold, they took to drinkingf the strong waters. The effect on Norwood was to refresh him, yet the captain fell, according to Norwood, into melancholy:

The poor captain fell to contemplate (as it better became him) our sad condition; and being troubled in mind for having brought so many wretched souls into misery, by a false confidence he gave them of his having a good ship, which he now thought would prove their ruin; and being conscious, that their loss would lie all at his door, it was no easy matter to appease his troubled thoughts. He made me a particular compliment for having engaged me and my friends in the same bottom, and upon that burst into tears. I comforted him the best I could, and told him, We must all submit to the hand of God, and rely on his goodness, hoping, that the same providence which had hitherto so miraculously preserved us, would still be continued in our favour till we were in safety. We retired obscurely to our friends, who had been wondering at our absence.

Approaching the shore on January 3rd, but having lost all sense of an accurate location, they were in a sorry state:

The weakness of the ship's crew, many dead and fallen over board, and the passengers weakened by hunger, dying every day on the decks, or at the pump, which with great difficulty was kept going, but must not rest.

Whereas the passengers wanted to anchor at sea and make for shore in the suviving wherry, an old, experienced officer , the husband of the ships's remaining stores, would not risk one remaining anchor. Yet, the counterargument was the near certainty of death by famine if the ship be forced out to sea againe by a north-west storm. The chief mate, Putt, was decisive, and various crew and passengers set out for the shore that day, including Norwood and the captain. The captaine chose to return to his ship, inviting Norwood bac, but Norwood declined, believing it had been agreed that the ship would not sail, and having found wild-fowl and oysters on the shore. He woke the next morning to see the ship under sail, to his amazement and confusion of mind, the seamen ("as we were told after") having set sail without the captain's order an in his absence on a change of wind promising a return to the Virginian coast.

Norwood estimated the number of people on shore at the time of the ship's departure to be nineteen, which is close to the twenty three mentioned in the petition of Priscilla Lockier and Sara Spurgeon. They were on an island, not the mainland as they had at first presumed.. But here Norwood's account diverges slightly from that of Lockier and Spurgeon. Norwood records that an oyster bed was their principal source of sustenance when on the island, with the occasional roast wild-fowl shot with the aid of a number of fowling pieces they had with them. Lockier and Spurgeon suggested the sole sustenace was from water and trees. The oysters were supplemented with a sort of weed " some four inches long, as thick as houseleek,and the only green (except pines) that the island afforded. It was very insipid on the palate; but being boiled with a little pepper (of which one had brought a pound on shore) and helped with five or six oysters, it became a regale for every one in turn." Yet the situation was dire, with the fowl becoming more cautious and fewer as they migrated, and Norwood and his companions , both men and women, ever weaker.

The petition's assertion of cannibalism is confirmed in Norwood's account, though without the drama of Lockier and Spurgeon's description of lots being drawn to shot a colleague for flesh to eat:

Of the three weak women before-mentioned, one had the envied happiness to die about this time; and it was my advice to the survivors, who were following her apace, to endeavour their own preservation by converting, her dead carcase into food, as they did to good effect. The same counsel was embrac'd by those of our sex: the living fed upon the dead; four of our company having the happiness to end their miserable lives on Sunday night the _ day of January. Their chief distemper, 'tis true, was hunger; but it pleased God to hasten their exit by an immoderate access of cold, caused by a most terrible storm of hail and snow at north-west, on the Sunday aforesaid, which did not only dispatch those four to their long homes, but did sorely threaten all that remained alive, to perish by the same fate.

The party was saved by the arrival and help of a number of Indians, who provided them with food and canoes to take them to the mainland, which was only a few hundred yards from the island. Of the nineteen men and women who had been on shore at depearture of the Virginia Merchant, thirteen remained, with four men and one woman dead, and a second woman missing.

---

Topics

---

---

---

---

---

---

Text

"About the fifteenth day of September, 1649, the "Virginia
Merchant," Captain John Locker, a ship of three hundred
tons burden, sailed for Jamestown with many passengers.
Among those who engaged passage were Colonel Norwood, a
relative of Governor Berkeley; Major Francis Morison, a
sympathizer with the King, and Major Stevens, (1) who had
served under Waller in the Parliamentary Army when it
besieged Exeter, then held by Sir John Berkeley, the Gov-
ernor's brother. Driven by a storm, the ship found itself
on the 12th of January, 1650, among the islands of
Assateague Bay, on the Atlantic coast of Maryland. Upon
one of these, Colonel Norwood, Major Morison, Stevens,
Francis Gary, and others landed, and after several days,
crossed over to the main land and were hospitably treated by
the Indians. A white fur trader, Jenkin Price, (2) arrived,
and under his guidance they began their journey to
Nathaniel Littleton's plantation, the nearest in Accomac.
Toward night of the first day, they reached a point opposite
Chincoteague Island, and at the close of the second day,
after twenty-five miles of travel, they came to Price's post
on the Littleton Plantation. From thence they proceeded to
the Plantation of Stephen Charlton, who gave them fresh
clothing. Lower down in Accomac, now Northampton
County, they visited Argoll Yeardley, the son of the former
Governor, who was born at Jamestown, in 1621, and had
recently married."

FOOTNOTES:

(1.) Major William Stevens probably for some time remained in Accomac,
where Yeardley and others held his political sentiments, and was perhaps
the same person who in March 1651 declared his fealty to the "common-
wealth of England as it is nowe established without Kins: or House of
Lords." He may have been the one who settled near the spot, where
he was cast away, in 1650, and thus became a citizen of Maryland. In
the records of Somerset County, Maryland, is the following: "Richard
Stevens, brother to William Stevens of Somerset County, in ye Province
of Maryland, was youngest son of John Stevens of Lebourn in ye Parish
of Buckingham in England, died at the house of his brother William
aforesaid, ye 22d day of April, 1667, and was buried at his plantation
called Rehoboth in ye county and province aforesaid, in America, ye
25th day of April."

In 1679, Col. William Stevens entered a tract of two thousand acres
on the shores of the upper part of Assateague Bay near where, in 1650,
the "Virginia Merchant's" passengers landed in distress.

(2) In October, 1650, the Assembly gave 5,000 pounds of tobacco to
Jenkin Price for the preservation of certain persons. Price was now
poor and evidently this was a gratuity for his kindness to Norwood,
now become Treasurer of Virginia.

(Norwood's narrative of his voyage and adventures is contained in A voyage to Virginia. Force's Collect. of Historical Tracts, vol. III)

---

Sources

---

Primary sources

Tracts and Other Paper Relating Principally to the Origin, Settlement, and Progress of the Colonies in North America From the Discovery of the Country to the Year 1776
A Voyage to Virginia
Vol. III., No. 10.
Colonel Norwood
Peter Force 50 pages, pp. 1-50
Peter Smith
Gloucester, Mass.
1963
E 187.F69 1963
Published: 1649

---